Baker's face shape and yours are far more similar than any of the others.
I know you want to look the most like Matt Smith, but it's just not accurate.
There are significant differences between what you look like and what all the doctors look like, because, you're not the exact same person as those actors. But, if you were going to cosplay as one, you should give Baker a shot - he's beloved, and you could probably pull it off, you have similar eyes and a face shape, and the costume is fun.
EDIT: You could probably pass for the Troughton or Davison doctors, with a bit of make-up and wigs, but I think Baker's your best bet.