He's handsome at least.
Cards on the table I think too much is made of the actor thing anyway. Whether Cruise was jumping on sofas or not I don't think his career is significantly any better now than when he did that, I don't think he has great likeability. He's in a position to choose the best scripts, most of which do middling box office for the past decade or so.
I don't think there's a single actor or actress in Hollywood that can sell a film solely on their name and have doubts it was ever the case, if it was it was fleeting.
Some have more charisma though, always an element and Renner can be a good supporting actor. Not a blockbuster lead by my estimation.