millarworld.tv Comics Creators

Doctor Who Thread of Space and Time: Discussing Twice Upon A Time (SPOILERS)


#2310

No I mean acting a bit odd more alien like not from earth I’d say the fifth doctor acted the most human of them all.


#2311

So… British?


#2312

I know it was just a wee joke :grinning:

I actually don’t find the oddness particularly Alien, but I think Troughton and McGann had the most ‘otherworldliness’ about them.


#2313

Really more so then Matt smith or Tom baker or McCoy.


#2314

We don’t tolerate this kind of racism on the board!


#2315

How about this rascism:

“Aye, dwi wedi meddwi’n chwil!”


#2316

Okay. We take it back and apologise. You’re not British.


#2317

Oh I’m most certainly British, the doubts are centred around the Anglo-Saxons. :wink:


#2318

Yeah, I think that while they are certainly ‘odd’ they show very human oddness… In fact I’d go as far as to say they show their love for humans and a kind of want to be one more than any others except for maybe Davison… Baker with his Jelly Babies… McCoy with his umbrella and a cuppa… Smith wearing a fez seems a ridiculously odd but British thing to do. Him and Davison could have a right quintessentially British off.


#2319

To address the question about who the most truly alien Doctor is, I would say maybe: Tom Baker or Eccleston. They just managed to work on a different type of logic.

Ultimately they were able to find the humanity in the character, so I am not sure how alien you could say they were.


#2320

Don’t forget pertwee he is the action Doctor he is all frills those magician type jackets.


#2321

Not having grown up with Doctor Who, Pertwee is the one who always seems not to sit right with the others. He is a bit too suave and a bit too together for me. And he is a bit of an authority figure.

To be honest, I haven’t watched a lot of the Third Doctor, so I could have the wrong impression of him.


#2322

When Pertwee starts he’s an absolute dick and the least human.


#2323

He is very arrogant. Too he was pretty rude to the Brigadier in the beginning too.


#2324

He is like I’m stuck on this planet with you Brigadier.


#2325

He was very angry cause he was exiled to earth.


#2326

By the Time Lords.


#2327

All of that plus they filmed a scene in a quarry! Drink!


#2328

I’m not sure that qualifies as, "the least human".


#2329

I dunno.

It was okay. Without Clara it’s just about an old guy fighting aliens.