Hmmm…fair question. I find it annoying when Silver Age concepts are treated as jokes, because yes we know they’re silly, but it’s because they’re so silly that you have to treat them completely deadpan-serious, otherwise the whole thing becomes a painfully unfunny joke. (See for example: Adam West as Batman.) As soon as you treat them as jokes… well they’re not actually very good jokes
But that’s just a personal view, and others may disagree.
By comparison, I thought the Fudd/Batman story was awesome, and I think it worked so well because it treated the story seriously.